Wood Density and Anatomical Properties in Suppressed-Growth Trees: Comparison of Two Methods


  • David W. Vahey
  • J. Y. Zhu
  • C. Tim Scott


SilviScan, tracheid, density, diameter, wall thickness, anisotropy, image analysis, resolution, suppressed growth, small diameter, thinnings, pulp


Interest in the commercial value of small-diameter timber has led to testing core samples with SilviScan to characterize density and transverse fiber dimensions. Data showed that latewood density and tracheid diameter in suppressed-growth material can vary spatially on a scale comparable to the 50-μm resolution of the instrument used in our testing. An optical imaging method called Ring Profiler was developed to determine what effect SilviScan's resolution had on the measurements. A single suppressed-growth specimen of Douglas-fir was used to develop the method. Ring Profiler measurements of the specimen showed that SilviScan overestimated latewood tracheid radial diameters by 59% in growth rings averaging 200-μm width. In those same growth rings, SilviScan latewood density was found to be 19% too low. In all growth rings measured by Ring Profiler, latewood wall thicknesses were anisotropic. Radial and tangential values averaged 13% less than the isotropic wall thickness calculated from SilviScan data. Ring Profiler density measurement from binarized images of wood cross-sections was found to correlate well with SilviScan X-ray density (r-squared = 0.907); however, better images and an objective method for thresholding are needed for accuracy over a large sample space. With these improvements and automated scanning of samples, Ring Profiler could be an attractive, inexpensive complement to SilviScan.


Cown, D. J. 1975. Variation in tracheid dimensions in the stem of a 26-year-old radiata pine tree. Appita28(4): 237-245.nDeGroot, R. C., and T. A. Kuster. 1986. SEM X-Ray microanalysis of tracheid cell walls in southern yellow pine sapwood treated with water-dispersible pentachlorophenol. Wood Fiber Sci.18(1):58-67.nEvans, R. 1994. Rapid measurement of the transverse dimensions of tracheids in radial wood sections from Pinus radiata.Holzforschung48(2):168-172.nEvans, R., G. Downes, D. Menz, and S. Stringer. 1995. Rapid measurement of variation in tracheid transverse dimensions in a radiate pine tree. Appita J.48(22):134-138.nEvans, R., R. P. Kibblewhite, and S. Stringer. 1997. Kraft pulp fiber property prediction from wood properties in eleven radiate pine clones. Appita J.50(11):25-33.nEvans, R., R. P. Kibblewhite, and M. Lausberg. 1999. Relationships between wood and pulp properties of twenty-five 13 year old radiate pine trees. Appita J.52(22):132-139.nGu, H., A. Zink-Sharp, and J. Sell. 2001. Hypothesis on the role of cell-wall structure in differential transverse shrinkage of wood. Holz Roh- Werkst.59:436-442nIvkovich, M., G. Namkoong, and M. Koshy. 2002. Genetic variation in wood properties of interior spruce. II Tracheid characteristics. Can J. For. Res.32:2128-2139.nJang, H. F., R. S. Seth, C.B. Wu, and B. K. Chan. 2005. Determining the transverse dimension of fibres in wood using confocal microscopy. Wood Fiber Sci.37(4):615-628.nJones, T. G., and S. R. Corson. 1996. Relationship of TMP and wood properties of radiata pine trees. Appita'96. p. 553.nKang, K.-Y., S. Y. Zhang, and S. D. Mansfield. 2004. The effects of initial spacing on wood density, fibre and pulp properties in jack pine (Pinus banksiana Lamb.). Holzforschung58(5):455-463.nKellogg, R. M., and F. F. Wangaard. 1969. Variation in the cell-wall density of wood. Wood Fiber1:180-204.nKibblewhite, R. P., and A. D. Bawden. 1991. Fiber and fiber wall response to refining in softwood and hardwood pulps, preprint, Current and Future Technologies of Refining Conference. PIRA, Leatherhead, UK.nKlungness, J. H., R. Gleisner, D. Mann, K. Scallon, J.Y. Zhu, E. Horn, and L. L. Edwards. 2006. Evaluation of forest thinning materials for TMP production. TAPPI J.5(4):17-22.nLiu, J., X. M. Diao, and T. Furuno. 2002. Quantitative analysis of morphological variation of cross sectional tracheids of Hinoki (Chamaecyparis obtus Endl.) near Knot by imaging processing. Holzforschung56(3):239-243.nMidorikawa, Y., Y. Ishida, and M. Fujita. 2005. Transverse shape analysis of xylem ground tissues by Fourier transform image analysis I: Trial for statistical expression of cell arrangements with fluctuation. J. Wood Sci.51: 201-208.nMurata, K. and M. Masuda. 2006. Microscopic observation of transverse swelling of latewood tracheid: Effect of macroscopic/mesoscopic structure. J. Wood Sci.52:283-289.nPalviainen, J., and R. Silvennoinen. 2001. Inspection of wood density by spectrophotometry and a diffractive optical element based sensor. Meas. Sci. Technol.12:345-352.nReme, P. A., and T. Helle. 2002. Assessment of transverse dimension of wood tracheids using SEM and image analysis. Holz Roh- Werkst.60:277-282.nRudie, A. W., J. Morra, J. M. St. Laurent, and K. L. Kickey. 1994. The influence of wood and fiber properties on mechanical pulping. TAPPI J.77(6):86-90.nSchimleck, L. R., and R. Evans. 2004. Estimation of Pinus radiata D. Don tracheid morphological characteristics by near infrared spectroscopy. Holzforschung58:66-73.nSchimleck, L. R., P.D. Jones, G.F. Peter, R.F. Daniels, and A. Clark III. 2004. Nondestructive estimation of tracheid length from sections of radial wood strips by near infrared spectroscopy. Holzforschung58:375-381.nSeth, R. S. 1990. Fibre quality factors in papermaking-II. The importance of fibre coarseness. Pages 143-161 in Materials Research Society Symposium Proceedings, Vol. 197. Materials Research Society, Pittsburgh, PA.nSeth, R. S., H. F. Jang, B. K. Chan, and C. B. Wu. 1997. Transverse dimensions of wood pulp fibers and their implications for end use. Pages 473-503 in The Fundamentals of Papermaking Materials; Transactions. 11th Fundamental Res. Symp. Cambridge, UK., C. F. Baker, ed., PIRA International, Leatherhead, UK.nSkinnarland, I., P. O. Johnsen, O. W. Gregersen, and T. Helle. 1995. Cross section characteristics of commercial papermaking pulp fibers, pages 91-93 in International Paper Physics Conference, Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario, CPPA (Tech. Sec.), Montreal, Canada.nZhu, J. Y., D. W. Vahey, T. C. Scott, and G. C. Myers. 2007. Effect of tree growth rate on papermaking fibre properties, in International Paper Physics Conference, Gold Coast, Australia. Pp. 415-422.n





Research Contributions